Battle #3, Guts Vs. Nightmare

Who would win in a fight?

  • Guts(From the Berserk Anime)

    Votes: 3 42.9%
  • Nightmare(From Soul Edge, Soul Blade, Soul Calibur 1 & 2)

    Votes: 4 57.1%

  • Total voters
    7
Dude are u saying thats the only reason why i like Berserk ?
Berserk is good for the charater development and story line ..And the blood spraying Violence..
 
No i'm saying considering the two people who did vote are anime fan's it was fairly obvious who they were going to pick, i like anime and the sc2 game. And people are just downing Nighty because he doesn't have his own anime. SC has probably the most interesting story out of any fighting game to date and i bet most people's opinions would change if he did have one.

And i still don't get how akuma thinks Nightmare looks stupid. lol
 
Last edited:
I like both knightmare and Gatsu but i DO like Gatz more...And as for SC I like it also ...I agree it would make a cool anime...But imo Gatsu is just a way better Fighter Imo....
 
LordAdam said:
I like both knightmare and Gatsu but i DO like Gatz more...And as for SC I like it also ...I agree it would make a cool anime...But imo Gatsu is just a way better Fighter Imo....


You wanna talk about better fighter about how many moves does he usally use. If u want to look at it from the game point of view I would say nightmare has many many more moves and would be a better fighter...
 
Last edited:
Vicman said:
That sh!t ain't even happening. Nightmare is joke compared to the God Hand, and that's what/who Guts is hunting down.

Did u even read sonic post with the facts?
 
Chrono-Trigger said:
Did u even read sonic post with the facts?

Don't start getting snippy young man, and yes I read it, I just know enough about Guts. Which BTW Sonic you barely touched on the later "post-eclipse" Guts which is much different than early pre Band of the Hawks, or even during the Band of the Hawks Guts. Shit it wouldn't even be a contest if we matched Manga Guts vs. Nightmare. The manga was much more brutal/violent and severe than anything the anime showed, and we don't even want to bring the Skull Knight into this argument! :tongue:

aowbs-01.gif
 
Vicman said:
Don't start getting snippy young man, and yes I read it, I just know enough about Guts. Which BTW Sonic you barely touched on the later "post-eclipse" Guts which is much different than early pre Band of the Hawks, or even during the Band of the Hawks Guts. Shit it wouldn't even be a contest if we matched Manga Guts vs. Nightmare. The manga was much more brutal/violent and severe than anything the anime showed, and we don't even want to bring the Skull Knight into this argument! :tongue:

aowbs-01.gif

Dude! this isn't Uber Omega Version this and that Guts Vs. Nighty. It's like me trying to to change and say Super Sonic owns knuckles. The point is Nightmare's history and over-all character is only represented through the game which shouldn't be used to determine by how fast the character is in the game but through the story. You make it sound as if Nightmare is called wet dreams.

I'm pretty Sure you wouldn't think nightmare is such a little wuss if they made a entire anime seires based off the entire story of soul calibur which spans every character. I barely touched into the future because it shouldn't matter for the argument of who would kill who from their basic premise.

I'm pretty sure if someone saw a 5 second clip of someone chopping people with a sword and blood vs. a cool looking video game character, and basing it entirely off of that Gut's would be auto-picked without hesitation.
 
That's not the point, you barely know anything about Guts and that's why I think you're severely underestimating him. Do you know that his sword is called the Dragon slayer?! Know why? Because it literally can slay a dragon in half with one fell swoop. All it takes is someone strong enough to weild it.

Also have taken into account Guts brand? The very thing that curses him to be haunted by demons for all eternity? Do you even know that what Guts is doing is turning the hands of fate, something even the Godhand cannot do? Point is Guts is alot more than a man possesed by an evil sword.

Nightmare is a good person being possesed by an evil blade.
The blade was shattered once before, Guts could do it again for good.
Nightmare has foughten other powerful men before, Guts is fighting against gods. Guts wins this match.
 
Vicman said:
That's not the point, you barely know anything about Guts and that's why I think you're severely underestimating him. Do you know that his sword is called the Dragon slayer?! Know why? Because it literally can slay a dragon in half with one fell swoop. All it takes is someone strong enough to weild it.

And know why Nightmare has been undefeatable thus far? Everyone he kills makes him more powerfull, powerfull opponents make him even more powerfull after killing them. He's at random running around killing people just to get more power, Yea that's why they call it the Soul Edge it takes peoples soul's. The sword doesn't just break. FIRST there were two sword's one was destroyed by someone close to the god's of her religion. The Unbalance of power when one of the swords was destroyed transferred the remaining energy into the air(making Kilik even the goodest of goodie good's go on a unstoppable killing spree) a.k.a the Evil Seed.

Thus, making the Second sword even more powerfull. The will to own this friggin thing is so strong that cervantes comes back from the dead even more powerfull and doesn't even age anymore. And all he wants is to reposses this sword. And the evilness radiating about it caused this to happen.

Also have taken into account Guts brand? The very thing that curses him to be haunted by demons for all eternity? Do you even know that what Guts is doing is turning the hands of fate, something even the Godhand cannot do? Point is Guts is alot more than a man possesed by an evil sword.

And Nightmare isn't just possed by the sword, it told him it would give him something and once he got it he vowed no one would kill him because the sword would fall into someone else's hands and turn them evil, even though he still considerably is in his half way sane mind. He is a demon too, did you not notice the malformed arm, and i'm sure the armour the most powerfull sword created on to him once he was grabbed by it is just going to magically crack.

The only people capable of destroying the sword are the people sent by various god's in soul calibur.

Nightmare is a good person being possesed by an evil blade.
The blade was shattered once before, Guts could do it again for good.
Nightmare has foughten other powerful men before, Guts is fighting against gods. Guts wins this match.

The only person who can break the sword is the person who wields the soul calibur, and even if it is destroyed cervantes and inferno would take him to hell.

:tongue:

And i've seen Berserk and read the manga and it's fun logging IRC when you guys talk about me. The only point i'm trying to make is that Nightmare isn't average, and just because you don't see him chopping heads off in sc like you see guts in berserk doesn't mean he is a wuss.... (that was more directed at adam) :tongue: IMO
 
Well no one says that nightmare is a wuss....Just cant stand up to guts in a fight and come out victor...

Btw u know i am only kidding when i chat,unless i say so....
 
No one is saying Nightmare is a wuss, but IMO he would lose in the end to Guts. It would be a great fight to see nonetheless. ...and I still think you get all pissy over this. :tongue: ;)
 
Vicman said:
No one is saying Nightmare is a wuss, but IMO he would lose in the end to Guts. It would be a great fight to see nonetheless. ...and I still think you get all pissy over this. :tongue: ;)




He does get all pissy. This thread should be closed for it's own good before someone gets a trout up the a$$.
 
Vicman said:
Don't start getting snippy young man, and yes I read it, I just know enough about Guts. Which BTW Sonic you barely touched on the later "post-eclipse" Guts which is much different than early pre Band of the Hawks, or even during the Band of the Hawks Guts. Shit it wouldn't even be a contest if we matched Manga Guts vs. Nightmare. The manga was much more brutal/violent and severe than anything the anime showed, and we don't even want to bring the Skull Knight into this argument! :tongue:

aowbs-01.gif

Ya u may know about guts but do u really know anything about nightmare. u guys sound like fan boys, all ur saying is that he would win because he gots str, he is fast, he gots a big sword, and oh ya i cant forget He KILLED LOTS OF BAD PEOPLE OMG!!!
 
Chrono-Trigger said:
Ya u may know about guts but do u really know anything about nightmare. u guys sound like fan boys, all ur saying is that he would win because he gots str, he is fast, he gots a big sword, and oh ya i cant forget He KILLED LOTS OF BAD PEOPLE OMG!!!

You're right I'm a Berserk fanboy, slap my ass and hit me with beancurds if you want.

BTW Your all t3h h0tz right now so expect some pantal rumblings soon. :tongue: :rofl:
 
Back
Top