Battle #3, Guts Vs. Nightmare

Who would win in a fight?

  • Guts(From the Berserk Anime)

    Votes: 3 42.9%
  • Nightmare(From Soul Edge, Soul Blade, Soul Calibur 1 & 2)

    Votes: 4 57.1%

  • Total voters
    7

Sonic X

"An Outcast In A World of Hypocricy"
Joined
Sep 28, 2002
Messages
1,482
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Age
41
Location
Someplace, where people don't have to wear armor o
Website
www.nextgengamers.com
Battle #3, Guts Vs. Nightmare

Me and adam were arguing on IRC about who would win, when i decided why not make a thread about it?

And if your going to post why, GIVE LOGICAL REASONS. Stupid replies will be purged.

GUTS(FROM THE ANIME SERIES BERSERK)
anime31.jpg

-
anime53.jpg


Bio:
Guts is truly the definition of strength and will. Born of a dead woman and raised by mercenaries he is one really tough character. No matter what goes wrong, or what is taken away from him he fights on and on, not stopping until every enemy in his path is destroyed.

As a young man he was raised by Gambino, a mercenary, after the woman who found him and cared for him had passed on from a disease. Gambino was a cruel and strict teacher and started training Guts at an early age so he could earn money in ongoing campaigns.

After Gambino was injured in a battle and driven insane with rage he attempted to kill Guts, only to be killed. Pursued by his once allies Guts wanders out on his own and becomes a formidable mercenary.

During one campaign he comes up against the legendary band of the hawk, but never actually has to face off against them. Seeing it's a losing battle, and having done their part the Hawks leave and Guts helps to defeat Bazu-so the 30 man slayer.

After the battle and while travelling some of the Hawks attempt to steal his money and end up getting destroyed by Guts and his huge sword - until he comes up against Caska, a female leader of the Hawks. While fighting her and almost defeating her, their leader Griffith interferes. A meeting that would change the course of Guts's life forever.

Through various events Guts becomes a leader in the Hawks and is instrumental to Griffith's ascension, and all too involved in the fall... One of the strongest warriors on the battlefield and slayer 100 men, Guts is not to be taken lightly.

In the first episode we get a glimpse of the legendary Dragon Slayer, Guts's ultimate weapon, although all of his swords are oversized and extremely powerful in his hands, this one is extremely special

VERSUS:

NIGHTMARE(Siegfried before going evil)(FROM SOUL EDGE, SOUL CALIBUR 1 AND 2 "Namco Video Games")

182.jpg

-
289.jpg



He who took the weapon cervantes owned...

Bio:
At one time, Nightmare committed countless cold-blooded murders while under the control of Soul Edge. All who knew of him feared his crimson gaze and his strange, one-eyed, giant blade.

Originally, he was the leader of a group of brigands known as the Black Wind, whose stronghold was located in the Black Forest near the Roman Empire. It was news of his father's death that drove him from his marauding lifestyle, resolving to find his father's killer.

Hearing word of a sword known as Soul Edge, he became convinced that he could slay his father's murderer if he found this ultimate weapon. He searched through the battlegrounds in every region he traveled. Eventually, he came across a sword in a Spanish harbor that emitted a strange aura beside the corpse of its owner, who appeared to be a pirate. The dead body returned to life, covered in flames, as if to protect the sword. Upon defeating the apparition, he reached for the hilt of the mysterious blade.

It was then that he heard the voice of Soul Edge, the sword that feeds on souls.

It told him that if he used the souls absorbed by the sword, he would be able to resurrect his father. Accepting his new goal, the man's body began to surge with the evil energy of the sword. The energy became a beautiful pillar of light that pierced the evening sky and dissipated into the atmosphere.

From that moment on, the man became Nightmare, the evil knight who would strike fear into every corner of Europe.

Having determined that the power Soul Edge had at that moment was insufficient to revive his father, Nightmare attacked village after village to nourish the blade. Not satisfied, he sought out those with strong souls to feed the evil sword.

The killings ended three years later, when Nightmare came across three sacrifices for his blade. One of them wielded a spirit sword called Soul Calibur, which possessed an aura that was the polar opposite of the evil power emitted by Soul Edge. The battle between the swordsmen took place in a vortex of hellfire and evil energy summoned by Soul Edge. After a raging battle, the evil sword shattered, and both Nightmare and Soul Edge fell into the collapsing void.

With Soul Edge severely weakened, Nightmare regained some of his humanity. Along with lucidity came the horrifying memories of the sins he committed, as well as the fear and anger of those who were slaughtered by him. Moreover, he realized that he had been the one who murdered his father.

Expelled from the void into an unfamiliar place, Nightmare disappeared into the night-the evil sword still in his grip. But Soul Edge was weaker now, and splinters of itself were left in Nightmare's footsteps.

He knew Soul Edge must never fall into the hands of another man. He set off to go as far away as possible from human settlements.

Yet each morning, he awakened to the sight of people slain by him during the night. While he slept, Soul Edge took over his mind and flesh, and he was burdened by this new guilt. Nevertheless, he did not choose to take his own life and end things easily. He knew that if he died, the sword would only find a new host to continue its evil ways. The only solution was to find a place where the evil could be imprisoned forever.

Initially, the balance of power between him and the sword were equal. But as time wore on, his control over his body became irregular, and the sword held sway over him for slightly longer periods of time.

The number of those who fell victim to the blade continued to grow. The sword healed itself gradually by feeding off the victims' souls. After four years, the sword had nearly recovered to full strength.

The fragments of itself lost during its escape...The evil energy dispersed as the Evil Seed…Soul Edge's shattered companion blade…the other Soul Edge...

With dominant control over its host body, Soul Edge, once again in the form of "Nightmare," began to pursue the fragments of itself that it had lost. It was on a quest to restore itself completely!

But at the same time, he continued to fight the evil sword's plans with the little sanity left within him.
 
Last edited:
Guts, he has the indomitable will to fight on irregardless of the odds. See the fight w/ Zodd the Immortal and the "Eclipse" as proof.
 
Guts hes got many weapons and the GODLY speed and strenght plus a fairy that heals him and when the odds are stacked against him hes at his best ...just too many reasons to list....
 
Last edited:
I like the mutanic look of Nightmare so yeah..
Never seen either in an actual show so...
 
Akuma said:
I personaly think Nightmare looks stupid... so I choose GUTS.

This isn't about who looks cooler, they're simular in the fact they both have big swords except the one is supposed to be an evil knight. And how can you think nightmare looks stupid? :sad:

It's about who would tear the other one apart.
 
Sonic X said:
This isn't about who looks cooler, they're simular in the fact they both have big swords except the one is supposed to be an evil knight. And how can you think nightmare looks stupid? :sad:

It's about who would tear the other one apart.





Evil knight eh? Wonder how he would do against a Ice Knight:


fc7d40be.jpg


:cool:
 
Im going with Nightmare tho i dont know much about guts, but between the power of nightmare and the Soul Edge the power of them cobmined would give "them" god like speed, strengh, and agility. And after he took Guts life, Nightmare would feed off of his soul to become even more powerful.
 
Chrono-Trigger said:
Im going with Nightmare tho i dont know much about guts, but between the power of nightmare and the Soul Edge the power of them cobmined would give "them" god like speed, strengh, and agility. And after he took Guts life, Nightmare would feed off of his soul to become even more powerful.
That sh!t ain't even happening. Nightmare is joke compared to the God Hand, and that's what/who Guts is hunting down.
 
For everyone who thinks they know everything about nighty just from playing the game....


The story begins with Captain Cervantes, one of the most dreadful pirates of the era. After he acquired the evil twin swords "Soul Edge", Cervantes and his mighty ship the "Adrian" struck fear into the Atlantic Ocean. Once fully possessed by the demon swords, he slew his entire crew and the residence of his port base in Spain. After the bloodshed, Cervantes rested himself at the remains of what was once known as the "Black Tail Inn". Temporarily satisfied with its twisted desire to consume souls, the evil swords rested and prepared to create the "Child of the Evil Swords"...


During the next twenty years, the rumors of the evil swords spread throughout the world. Some believed it was the sword of salvation, while others called it the ultimate weapon. Some, selected by destiny and history, sought Soul Edge for personal reasons. Fortunately, few reached Soul Edge; those that did cursed their fate as the evil swords devoured their souls.


However there was one who fought the cursed fate... Sophitia, the sacred fighter of Hephaestus the God of Blacksmiths. During the grueling battle with Cervantes, she succeeded in destroying one of the twin swords. But in doing so, she was wounded as the pieces of the shattered sword rained upon her body. Cervantes, with wrath as if a part of him had been destroyed, was about to end her life when Taki the "Underground Hunter" challenged him.


Due to his loss of control from the destruction of one of the blades, the intense battle between Taki and Cervantes ended with the victory of the "Underground Hunter". She completed her mission by gathering a piece of the destroyed Soul Edge and left with the injured Sophitia.


Siegfried, the "Innocent Darkside," visited the port town seeking the sword of legend for his vengeance, only to find the corpse of a pirate captain. Attracted by a sword clutched in the dead pirate’s hand, Siegfried walked toward it take possession of the blade, but suddenly the corpse rose up enveloped in hell fire. It seemed as if an evil spirit had materialized on earth consuming Cervantes' body.


With a flash, mortal combat began. The Zweihander "Faust", roared in the hands of the boy, who seemed too little to bear such a heavy blade, and slashed through the air controlled by the madness in the youth's eyes. When the battle ended, all that remained was the burnt corpse and the boy grasping the now broken Zweihander. His green eyes reflected the Soul Edge bathed in hell fire...


The youth’s warped spirit extended a hand to Soul Edge, as if being guided by the evil spirit which longed for a new host to maintain its power and control...

That night, some people at the Spanish seashore saw a mysterious but beautiful scene of a white column of light piercing the clouds and spreading through the sky. How could they have known, it was the birth of the Evil Seed, which would cause disasters throughout the world?



No one knew where the rumor came from.

The blue knight, with the mysterious crimson eyes, bore the huge sword in its malformed right hand. No one who saw the crimson eyes of the knight, from strong fighters to shrieking women, from innocent babies to tiny worms, could escape its blade as it devoured their souls. The single eye of the huge sword looked like it was smiling in enrapturement, as it tasted the blood of living things. Only the creatures of darkness that served its cold blade were exempt from its fevered hunger for new souls.

"Rumor, it's only a rumor." "Damn rumors all..."

Three years after the Spanish village saw the column of light, a small German village was in for a night of death as a knight with crimson eyes stood atop a cliff with the full moon to his back. It swallowed towns and villages in its path to the Black Woods. It was as if Captain Cervantes returned, but with a dreadfulness and evil far surpassing the original!

"We are coming, father…"


Oh yea... Nightmare fights Demon's too, Cervy and Astaroth, An Astaroth himself was made by the masters of dark magic and is only of 6 years old.

And besides that, people want this sword so damn bad that cervantes comes back from the dead just to get it back. Astaroth was created for the purpose of maintaining it. Xianghua was sent to destroy as was Sophitia and Taki. People like Kilik have gone mad and killed people because of the imbalance of power, People like Ivy want to destroy it for revenge. Voldo want's it as a collector's item. etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Vicman said:
That sh!t ain't even happening. Nightmare is joke compared to the God Hand, and that's what/who Guts is hunting down.

Nightmare isn't going to just die, even after he figures out that the sword has taken over him and realized all the evil things he has done he vow's to use the little sanity in him to allow NO ONE else to take the sword. Even if Guts did kill him the sword would tempt him to take hold of it and be taken to the dark side. And the sword still control's him like an On and Off Evil Switch.
 
Well Guts is allready plagued by demons with the brand on his neck ...And Guts likes his dragon slayer he was offered a magical sword instead but stuck with the slayer.....
 
LordAdam said:
Well Guts is allready plagued by demons with the brand on his neck ...And Guts likes his dragon slayer he was offered a magical sword instead but stuck with the slayer.....

Adam i don't think you understand the Universe rule when you argue a fight over two people from different Universes. Soul Calibur wise, anyone who touches this sword get's controlled by the sword itself, it's alive and tempts others to take it for it being known as the ultimate weapon.
 
I would like to see Nightmare (at least from the game :tongue: ) win but I think Gutz is faster so he is the one I choose
 
Back
Top